The Best Alternative Mattress Toppers – From Alpaca Wool To Goose Down

Read our review of the top and best alternative mattress toppers for goose duck, alpaca wool and Egyptian cotton.

If you are in a hurry and just want to know what the best alternative mattress topper is, I recommend the Avocado Vegan Mattress Topper.

Mattress pads or toppers change the feel of your sleeping surface to make it more comfortable and suited to your needs.

To achieve this, the toppers can be made of natural or synthetic materials or a combination of both.

Sometimes, toppers can be made of certain materials to mimic the feel of others. For example, fleece toppers can mimic the best wool mattress toppers.

Such inventions have opened unlimited opportunities for more sleepers to get similar comfort without having to compromise on their preferred topper materials, hence the popularity of alternative mattress toppers.

Below is a review of the best alternative mattress toppers to help you choose one that resonates with your needs.

Today I am reviewing the following alternative mattress toppers:

Alternative Egyptian Cotton Mattress Toppers

Alternative Goose Duck Mattress Toppers

Alternative Alpaca Wool Mattress Topper

Alternative Egyptian Cotton Mattress Toppers

Subrtex 4″ Gel-Infused High Density Cooling Memory Foam Mattress Topper -With Removable Fitted Bamboo Cover

BedtimeSpecialist.com - Helping you sleep at night

subrtex 4 Inch Gel-Infused Memory Foam Bed Mattress Topper High Density Cooling Pad Removable Fitted Bamboo Cover Ventilated Design-10 Years Warranty (King)

Featuring ventilated design gel-infused memory foam, this is the best mattress topper for every sleeping position. With thicknesses of 2, 3, and 4 inches, every sleeper can find their comfort level, pressure points relief, and a cool sleeping experience. 

The thicker topper especially works great with a sagging mattress.

The Subrtex topper is Oeko-Tex and CertiPUR-certified. It comes with a bamboo rayon washable cover that is meshed to keep it from sliding along your hard mattress. 

Further, the cover comes with adjustable straps that can accommodate mattress depths up to 12 inches and is zippered for easy removal and cleaning.

The mattress topper for side sleepers is backed by a 10-years warranty and comes in  California king, king, queen, full, twin XL, and twin sizes. It is also rated by over 6k customers on Amazon.

Novilla 4 Inch Gel & Bamboo Charcoal Infused Memory Foam Topper Mattress Topper with Breathable Bamboo Cover

BedtimeSpecialist.com - Helping you sleep at night

Novilla 4 Inch King Size Mattress Topper, Medium Firm Memory Foam Mattress Topper King, Gel & Bamboo Charcoal Infused for Motion Isolation & Pressure Relieving, with Breathable Bamboo Cover, King Size

The Novilla memory foam mattress topper features a 2-layer design. 

A 2.5 inches thick bamboo charcoal foam offers a moisture-wicking base support layer while 1.5 inches of cooling gel-infused high-density memory foam helps in isolating motion, providing comfort, and relieving pressure points.

In addition, the memory foam layer features an open-cell and egg crate design to maximize airflow and improve temperature regulation, especially for hot sleepers.

The mattress topper comes with a super-soft, breathable, and skin-friendly bamboo cover. It is machine washable with non-slip particles at the base and 4 corner elastic straps to keep the topper in place.

Novilla memory foam topper features Oeko-Tex Standard and CertiPUR-US certified premium materials.

This topper is suitable for all sleep positions and is available in king, queen, full, and twin sizes. It is backed by a 3-year warranty, a 30-days money back guarantee, and 24/7 customer support.

Alternative Goose Duck Mattress Toppers

Sleep Mantra Store Cooling Pillow Top Mattress Topper

BedtimeSpecialist.com - Helping you sleep at night

Cooling Mattress Topper King, Pillow-Top Optimum Thickness, Soft 100% Cotton Fabric & Down-Like Fill, Plush Mattress Pad Snug Fits 8 - 20 inch Deep Mattresses

With over 12k reviews on Amazon, the Sleep Mantra plush mattress topper is also a popular synthetic alternative to the best wool mattress toppers.

The mattress topper is designed to offer a plush comfort layer that can significantly improve the feel of an old mattress.

Made of polyester fiber fill quilted in an organic cotton cover, the mattress pad boasts optimum thickness perfect for relieving pressure points while giving the needed support.

Outstanding breathability and moisture wicking properties of the 300 thread count cotton cover helps with temperature regulation, ensuring a cool environment even for those who sleep hot.

The down alternative topper is skirted with pockets up to 18 inches deep to fit snugly over your mattress.

It is easy to clean as it is stain and water repellent. When necessary, the pillow top pad can also undergo machine washing without losing its shape and quality.

Although it is made of synthetic fibers, the topper is certified by Oeko-Tex Standards to be free of harmful chemicals. It is available in California king, king, queen, full, twin XL, and twin sizes.

Duck And Goose Co Overfilled Pillow Top Mattress Topper

BedtimeSpecialist.com - Helping you sleep at night

D & G The Duck And Goose Co Overfilled Overfilled Extra Thick Plush Mattress Topper Queen Size, Overfilled Mattress Pillowtop Bed Topper for Best CushioningExtra Thick Mattress Topper Queen Size

Duck and Goose Co mattress topper is suited for a firm mattress. It is filled with 1400GSM gel-fiber enclosed in a soft, skin-friendly, and breathable shell for a cool and cozy sleep experience.

With 2-inches loft, the thick topper offers luxurious comfort for all sleep positions. It is quilted for even distribution of fill and fitted with elastic anchor bands to secure it to your mattress.

The alternative Duck and Goose down topper is machine washable. The manufacturers recommend a bi-annual wash in a front loader machine and a tumble dry on low heat.

This mattress topper boasts over 10k reviews on Amazon. Available sizes include queen, short queen, full XL, full, twin XL, and twin.

LUCID 4 Inch Down Alternative and Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper

BedtimeSpecialist.com - Helping you sleep at night

LUCID 4 Inch Down Alternative and Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper - Three Toppers In One - King , White

If you want to combine the best of memory foam and down alternative, this is your topper. The lucid mattress topper features a 2-inch layer of down alternative over a two-inch layer of memory foam.

The plush top part is machine washable. It is made of fiberfill quilted in a 100% cotton cover to give it airy, soft, and down-like comfort.

The gel-infused memory foam part is designed for contoured support and ventilated for temperature regulation. It is advisable to allow memory foam mattress toppers up to 72 hours to fully decompress after unpacking.

Unlike with other toppers, you can use the two layers of this topper separately or together, giving you the option of three sleeping experiences.

To keep everything in place, the topper comes with a fitted sheet design. It is available in California king, king, queen, full, twin XL, and twin.

Alternative Alpaca Wool Mattress Topper

Holy Lamb Organics Eco-Wool Mattress Topper With Organic Cotton Cover

BedtimeSpecialist.com - Helping you sleep at night

Holy Lamb Organics Wool Mattress Toppers (King Deep Sleep Topper)

Crafted from GOTS-certified organic wool batting encased in an organic cotton shell, the Holy Lamb wool topper is hand-made in Oakville, WA by Holy Lamb Organics. The brand’s organic bedding materials are domestically sourced and have attained several certifications and testing

In addition, the Holy Lamb Organics natural wool toppers have been featured in the Oprah Magazine and ABC World News.  

This high-quality wool mattress pad is cozy, breathable, and designed to sit well on your mattress.

It comes in 2 thicknesses; Deep Sleep that is approximately 1.5- 2 inches thick and Ultimate which is about 2.5- 3 inches thick. 

Available sizes include California king, king, queen, full, twin XL, twin, and crib which comes with elastic straps. Crib toppers are machine washable but the rest only require airing, sunning, and spot cleaning. To make it easy to maintain, you can use it with a machine washable cover or a fitted sheet.

Avocado Vegan Mattress Topper

BedtimeSpecialist.com - Helping you sleep at night

This company also makes a great alpaca organic wool topper.

But if you are looking for an alternative to their organic wool toppers, then this is a good choice.

This topper stands out as a perfect alternative to the best wool mattress topper thanks to its combination of all natural materials.

Handmade in California, the topper features a support core made of 2-inches GOLS certified organic latex that comes in two firmness options.

The firm topper is ideal for a soft mattress and side sleepers while the plush topper works best with a mattress that’s too firm and is suitable for back and stomach sleepers.

The comfort layer features quilted GOTS certified organic cotton batting. A breathable, soft, and moisture wicking organic cotton cover gives the topper a hypoallergenic finish.

The alternative organic wool topper is Vegan Certified by Vegan Action to be free of animal products. The manufacturers discourage machine wash and recommend spot cleaning instead.

They offer a money-back guarantee within the first 365 days after a trial of at least 30 days. The topper is also backed by a 10-year limited warranty.

The Avocado organic topper is available in California king, king, queen, full, twin XL, and twin sizes.

Conclusion

The above list consists of the best alternative mattress toppers in the market. Regardless of your needs and preferences, you can always find alternative mattress toppers for your unique size, design, material combination, thickness, and density. 

You should also be on the lookout for after sale services such as trial periods, money back-guarantees, and manufacturer warranties.

The above toppers not only boast the best certifications in the industry but also come reviewed and best-rated by numerous customers worldwide. 

At a glance, here’s what what we have concluded:

Editor’s Choice For Best Alternative Egyptian Cotton Mattress Topper

Novilla 4 Inch Gel & Bamboo Charcoal Infused Memory Foam Mattress Topper with Breathable Bamboo Cover

Novilla 4 Inch King Size Mattress Topper, Medium Firm Memory Foam Mattress Topper King, Gel & Bamboo Charcoal Infused for Motion Isolation & Pressure Relieving, with Breathable Bamboo Cover, King Size

Editor’s Choice For Best Alternative Goose Duck Mattress Topper

Sleep Mantra Store Cooling Pillow Top Mattress Topper

Cooling Mattress Topper King, Pillow-Top Optimum Thickness, Soft 100% Cotton Fabric & Down-Like Fill, Plush Mattress Pad Snug Fits 8 - 20 inch Deep Mattresses

Editor’s Choice For Best Alternative Alpaca Wool Mattress Topper

Avocado Vegan Mattress Topper

Things to consider when buying an alternative mattress topper

Ethical

Ethical sourcing in alternative topper materials means that the right social, economical, cultural standards are met in the whole manufacturing process.

More specifically, this also applies to adherence to good labor law standards. Most brands will indicate this or show relevant certifications.

Sustainability

This refers to the ability of the materials used to be produced in constant supply presently and in the future without depleting non-renewable resources or negatively impacting the environment.

Animal Welfare

Where animal-derived materials are used in the making of bedding, animal welfare seeks to ensure that no animals are subjected to inhumane treatment in the process of material sourcing across all the supply chains.

Organic or Environmentally Friendly

Completely organic materials are usually indicated as certified organic. Good examples include organic wool, organic cotton, and organic latex. These are materials farmed without the use of harmful chemicals and fertilizers. 

Environmentally friendly toppers can be made of natural or synthetic materials as long as they don’t negatively impact the environment during processing, use, or disposal.

Longevity

This is the ability to last for a long time. The longevity of a topper may depend on material, frequency of use, the condition of your mattress, and care among other factors. 

That said, natural latex and wool mattress toppers are sturdier and can last for over 10 years, followed by memory foam and fiber in that order.

Toxicity or Off-Gassing

Off-gassing is the release of volatile compounds or ‘new mattress smell’ associated with polyurethane foam, such as memory foam, bedding. According to research, these gases are usually in levels too low to cause health problems.

People with sensitivities and babies may, however, experience effects such as headaches and eye, nose, and throat irritation depending on the level of exposure.

 

Share on facebook
Share on pinterest
Share on twitter
Share on linkedin
Share on whatsapp
Share on email
Share on print